Final Fantasy XI: Wings of the Goddess
Best Final Fantasy MMORPG Expansion
Let’s kick this off by saying none of the expansions for either of the Final Fantasy MMORPGs are objectively terrible. Obviously, some are better than others which is why we’re ranking them, but even the last place entry on this list isn’t an offensively bad expansion.
Speaking of which, that leads us to our first entry. Final Fantasy XI: Wings of the Goddess. The Crystal War is one of the most pivotal moments in recent Vana’diel history and many fans were looking forward to seeing what the Middle Lands were like prior to the events of the war. Sadly, in a lot of ways it was quite underwhelming.
Zones in Wings of the Goddess were a nightmare to traverse (Jugner Forest anyone?) and in reality didn’t really add much visual flair. The few actual new zones that were added weren’t anything special either.
Previous expansions added content that became staples for years to come but unfortunately that wasn’t the case with this expansion.
It’s not all bad though. Dancer and Scholar are both excellent jobs that turned out well in both the immediate aftermath and beyond.
And although the pacing of the story was a mess (large gaps in-between updates, and having to work through your own nation’s line in addition to the primary story), all-in-all the story scenario was extremely memorable and arguably the best in all of Final Fantasy XI. It’s just too bad so much else went wrong.
Final Fantasy XI: Rise of the Zilart
Best Final Fantasy MMORPG Expansion
It may not be completely obvious to non-Japanese players of Final Fantasy XI, but Rise of the Zilart is technically an expansion that was included with the original game in its worldwide launch.
Rise of the Zilart added a hefty load of fan-favorite zones such as The Sanctuary of Zi’Tah. There was the fabled “Sky” areas which could only be unlocked by completing a majority of the story and would be a staple of FFXI’s end game for years to come.
And also, it featured two classic boss fights: the battle against the Ark Angels, and the final fight against Eald’narche, each with appropriately amazing music.
The main issue with Rise of the Zilart is that prior to reaching Sky, aka The Shrine of Ru’Avitau, the story is nothing to write home about at least in comparison to other quest lines on this list.
Also, the three new jobs added Dragoon, Ninja, and Samurai were mostly a mess. Samurai in fairness was great out of the box and would be a staple job pretty much for the entirety of FFXI’s life, but the other two not so much.
After a very brief stint as the top damage dealer, Dragoon was nerfed into oblivion and it took many years before it ever (if ever honestly, Angon helped a bit) would be considered top tier again.
Ninja on the other hand was a total failure as a damage dealing class (its original intent) but crafty players eventually figured out that it actually worked better as a tank and had a pretty solid run in that role until the present day where it currently performs better as a DPS in most cases.
Final Fantasy XI: Seekers of Adoulin
Best Final Fantasy MMORPG Expansion
Unless you’re a very hardcore fan of Final Fantasy XI, it’s likely you never made it this far into FFXI’s lifespan to enjoy Seekers of Adoulin. Wings of the Goddess, the Abyssea battle packs, and the release of Final Fantasy XIV, was a gut shot to the game’s player base and effectively moved it out from its prime and into the back nine of its life.
That said, the Seekers of Adoulin meta actually achieved a lot to bring FFXI up to modern day standards. The addition of trusts made it so anyone can reach the level cap without having to wait for party invites anymore.
Home points and field manuals were updated to provide useful transportation across Vana’diel’s massive landmass, and the addition of Job Points finally helped many jobs that had been struggling for years and made them relevant and fun again. Speaking of jobs, both of the new jobs in Seekers of Adoulin were fantastic.
Geomancer, one of the most requested jobs in FFXI’s lifespan, became arguably the most powerful and critical job in the game, even bumping staple support job Bard from its throne.
Rune Fencer eventually became a very unique and useful tank, and a respectable DPS in certain situations as well, after some experimenting from players.
Seekers of Adoulin was great because it shook up FFXI dramatically but not in a way that changed the game’s identity that players had grown to love from its heyday. Abyssea unfortunately did that, but SoA (alongside the Rhapsodies of Vana’diel final scenario) was able to right those wrongs over the course of its run.
The biggest knock on Seekers of Adoulin is its story, which while commendable and features the beloved Arciela, is quite bloated and runs on way too long.
Final Fantasy XIV: Heavensward
Best Final Fantasy MMORPG Expansion
Final Fantasy XIV: Heavensward was pretty divisive. If you were coming into it off of a long break, or were starting with FFXIV for the first time, then Heavensward actually was probably pretty great to you.
The problem was then active players at the time were treated to an end game that was identical to what they had spent hours grinding in A Realm Reborn.
This is a problem that would persist throughout the series, but was an unfortunate shock in Heavensward, and was coupled with other problems out of the gates.
Also, the new jobs that they added, two of them were quite similar jobs already in the game. Paladin and Dark Knight shared lots of similarities at the time, while Astrologian lacked a unique healing style of its own and instead just swaps between a Scholar-style stance and a White Mage-style stance. While this has been rectified somewhat over time it was a disappointment at first.
The new areas, while beautiful, were a pain to traverse until you found enough aether currents to fly which was a brutally frustrating process.
Luckily, a lot of aspects of Heavensward improved through major patch releases such as the end game getting more varied.
The one thing Heavensward really had going for it at launch was its storyline which is an amazing effort that wouldn’t be outdone until years later by Shadowbringers. This fact coupled with the improvements it would see over time helps Heavensward leap frog a few entries up on this list.
Final Fantasy XIV: Stormblood
Best Final Fantasy MMORPG Expansion
Next we’re up to Final Fantasy XIV. Stormblood, the game’s second major expansion.
Its main scenario questline is yet another feather in the cap of Final Fantasy XIV’s writing achievements. Unlike Heavensward, the two new jobs it added, Red Mage and Samurai, were powerful, unique, and fun to play right out of the gates.
The host of job action changes it added at the time on its launch dramatically improves the quality of life for all of FFXIV’s jobs, making gameplay more streamlined and creates more recognizable and appreciated differences between each job’s styles.
Kugane is a gorgeous new city that players can explore and field areas such as the Azim Steppes, channels positive vibes from both Final Fantasy X and Final Fantasy XIII. Zenos is an excellent primary antagonist whose actions will have you rooting hard for yourself to take him down.
While Heavensward might have the better story, Stormblood was just far better put together at launch and edges it out slightly.
Final Fantasy XI: Chains of Promathia
Best Final Fantasy MMORPG Expansion
Chains of Promathia was initially controversial because of its lack of new jobs and how much of the new areas were gated behind difficult story content. However, over time, those sins were forgiven as the CoP story line wound up being one of the most memorable in Final Fantasy  XI’s history.
Featuring memorable characters such as Tenzen and Prishe, the CoPÂ story line was full of twists, turns, and memorable battles and moments. It was also really freaking hard, but it at least had a huge payoff for players that stuck with it: entry into the gorgeous (and important) AlTaieu area known as “Sea.”
Sea, like Sky before it, was a massive collection of zones that featured loads of end game content such as the Jailer NM tree and Limbus. Combined with the still very relevant Sky events, Final Fantasy XI was put in a very diverse and enjoyable state thanks to Chains of Promathia as long as you could tough it out through the story missions.
CoP was memorable because it didn’t hand the player anything just for participating with minimal effort/knowledge like many MMORPGs do. The story content was the meat of this expansion and like other video games that are difficult, you had to earn the credits that rolled at the end.
That said, it wasn’t everyone’s cup of tea and the difficulty turned off many players. Others that come up with a similar list might put Chains of Promathia toward the bottom for the very same reasons we have it high up on ours.
Finally, although not necessarily a highlight or lowlight, Chains of Promathia added the legendary enemy, Absolute Virtue, whose strategy for defeat remained a mystery for years.
Final Fantasy XI: Treasures of Aht Urghan
Best Final Fantasy MMORPG Expansion
Treasures of Aht Urghan tops our list of the best Final Fantasy MMORPG expansions. For many players, it was the last expansion that they would fully experience.
Unlike the previous two Final Fantasy XI expansions (Chains and Zilart) which took place primarily on the mainland, ToAU sent players to a new area of the world, to a city that would be the game’s main hub for years to come, Aht Urghan.
ToAU added a TON of brand new content including new field HNMs, the Zeni NM system, Einherjar, Assaults, Mythic Weapon quests etc. It also added three new and very unique jobs that played like nothing else before it.
A fully-fledged Blue Mage job that was true to the series roots, requiring players to learn skills from enemies (and there was a ton), a gambler-like support/DPS class, Corsair, and the customizable pet class, Puppetmaster.
Yeah, it took a very long time for Puppetmaster to ever get accepted and suffered a fate similar to Dragoon (although nowadays it’s one of the better jobs for both DPS, soloing, and even tanking in certain fights), but credit the FFXI development team for taking a stab at trying something very different.
And of course, as is a running theme in this list, the quest line for Treasures of Aht Urghan was fantastic. Perhaps not as memorable as Chains of Promathia, but still definitely up there.
The fact that it had a great story, and added lots of new areas, and had fun new jobs is what made Treasures of Urghan so great. It was a well put together coherent package of content that was expansive and for the most part, incredibly successful.
Final Fantasy XIV: Shadowbringers
Best Final Fantasy MMORPG Expansion
Finally, we arrive at the most recent, and without a doubt best expansion pack between the two Final Fantasy MMORPGs: Final Fantasy XIV: Shadowbringers.
What can we say about Shadowbringers that we didn’t already wax poetic about in our review?
Well pretty much nothing, because we said it all, but allow me to remind you in case you forgot. Shadowbringers is arguably a top five Final Fantasy story of all-time. Not just for MMORPGs, top five for any Final Fantasy. It holds its own against VI, VII, VIII, IX, X; whatever your favorite is.
And by extension, if you consider the Final Fantasy games to have among the best story lines of all-time, then you could also argue that Shadowbringers is one of the best RPG tales ever told.
While the Final Fantasy XI expansions definitely had their moments, none ever reached that level of recognition. The same can also be said for Shadowbringer’s incredible OST. The proof can be seen in the incredible user and critic score featured on Metacritic.
The story follows the player character and scions as they are sent to a completely different but still connected world shard. All of the scions, sans the player character, are trapped on this shard that is doomed to be destroyed.
Emet-Selch, the game’s primary antagonist, is among the most complex, interesting, and well-received villains in the series’ history and absolutely is the star of the show.
The expansion adds a completely brand new world filled with unique and gorgeous environments, two successfully implemented jobs in Gunbreaker and Dancer, and another round of mostly well-received job updates.
When you think Final Fantasy, you think story, and it just makes sense that the expansion with by far the best story tops this list.
What does your list look like? Let us know in the comments.
Published: Jul 20, 2020 05:09 pm