God of War vs. Spider-Man: Which PS4 Exclusive is Better
Story
When it comes to narrative, we’re pleased to say that both games represent the pinnacle of their respective series. Particularly in the case of God of War, Kratos’ PS4 adventure is a huge step up in terms of storytelling this time. As for Spidey, Insomniac Games has produced an exciting story that is genuinely impactful while simultaneously hitting all the beats of a triumphant superhero tale.
Of course, God of War’s emphasis on story is a huge departure from what we typically associate with the series. The narrative is more mature, just like Kratos himself, whose relationship with his son forms the crux of the story. That special bond and the back and more forth banter between all the characters is a real highlight. Each character is brought to life with some clever writing, and there’s a nice balance between comic relief and more poignant moments. Overall, Sony Santa Monica certainly did a great job weaving in Kratos’ battle with his past to showcase his changed personality and depth of character.
With Spider-Man, Insomniac definitely made the right call writing a unique story for Peter Parker. We were pleased that it detailed an older Spider-Man in his prime, rather than the origins stories that are usually so popular. The characters and story beats were familiar to long-time fans but easy enough for newcomers to understand and appreciate. In particular, Parker and Dr. Octavius’ relationship was really great to watch unfold. In fact, we’d tip Otto to be remembered as one of the better villains of this console generation. His fall from grace, from gentle do-gooder to a twisted maniac, was totally gripping.
Outside the game’s most thrilling face-offs, though, Spider-Man also distinguishes itself. The relationship between Parker and MJ, and the touching moments with Aunt May were all superbly done. Miles Morales was equally cool, too, and added a different layer to the narrative. Ultimately, it was the pacing between all these different elements that stood out. Apart from one or two lulls around the three-quarter mark, we were locked in from start to finish.
In the end, we’re tipping this section of the contest in favor of Spider-Man. That might come as controversial to some given that much as made of God of War’s emotional story. But honestly, apart from the final twist regarding Atreus’ background, it was all slightly predictable and one-dimensional. There were twists and turns, sure, but overall, not as much going on as in Spider-Man. Finally, both games tee-up a sequel, but God of War did so with less finesse. Where Spider-Man alluded to potential future storylines, God of War actually felt as though it had denied us a more interesting one by neglecting certain antagonists.
Winner: Spider-Man
