Episode 5
Mystery Man Clue #12 Cigar Box – Once in the Sanatorium as Mike, after being hassled by the dog, you can keep walking in and you’ll see the hard to miss flashing cigar box.
Mystery Man Clue #13 Clipping Wall – After getting the cigar box, head right and into the tiny, caged room to see a wall with various clippings all around.
Mystery Man Clue #16 Axe – As Matt wading through the snow with Emily, you’ll be able to pull a hard to miss flashing axe stabbed into a door.
Mystery Man Clue #14 Business Card – When you’re playing as Sam in the towel at the lodge, leave the bathroom and head down the stairs. Then, head to the right of the screen through the doors into a room where a flashing business card will be on an end table next to a plant.
Note: When Sam is being chased by the psycho, you need to make sure she gets away so that she can then get the rest of the Mystery Man clues in Episode 7. Hide in the elevator when you get the chance to.
