Xbox One X vs. PS4 Pro: Is the Xbox One X Worth It?

Is The Xbox One X Worth It If You Own a PS4 Pro?

Xbox One X vs. PS4 Pro

The Xbox One X is here and gamers are going to have to make an unusual choice that they don’t normally have to make. They will have to decide if they want to pick up a true new mid-gen console or not. The PS4 Pro came out last year with some impressive specs of its own, but the Xbox One X is as powerful as advertised. If you want the most powerful home console currently on the market capable of making games look as good as they possibly can (PC excluded of course), then you’re going to need to pony up the $500 for the Xbox One X.

That said, if you already own a home console, in this case the PS4 Pro, is it really worth the $500 to upgrade to the Xbox One X? Cost is relative and it’s going to depend if you can afford it or not. If money is no object, then sure grab the Xbox One X too. It’s a great console and if you can afford whatever you want then why not, right? Disregard anything we’re going to say in this article. But in the likely event that you’re someone that is on the fence and wants to be careful with their money, this guide is for you.

We’ll break down the biggest and most relevant differences between the two consoles and then give a verdict on whether or not the Xbox One X is still worth getting if you already own a PS4 Pro.

Performance

The PS4 Pro and the Xbox One X are close but not quite evenly matched. There will be many consumers that either don’t notice or don’t mind the slight differences between the two consoles. That said, the Xbox One X is the more powerful of the two home consoles in just about every category that would matter to anyone. You can see the full specification break down above.

The PS4 Pro will upscale many games to appear close to 4K but will not always be able to handle 60 FPS while also achieving that resolution. The Xbox One X, on the other hand, will have an easier time of handling true 4K and 60 FPS because of its increased horsepower. It’s something that developers will need to decide to take advantage of, if they want to be “Xbox One Enhanced” but the framework for it is there and you best believe Microsoft will be pushing it for their exclusive games and hope others follow suit.

Aside from that, the Xbox One X has the ability to improve loading times, but it’s not like the PS4 Pro is sluggish though where it would make a huge difference. It, too, improves the overall speed over the original PlayStation 4. The most important factor to consider here is how important true 4K and 60 FPS is to you.

Online Play and Unique Features

Xbox One X vs. PS4 Pro

Both consoles have a wealth of features unique to their platform (games excluded which we’ll get to separately below), that anyone considering either, or both, need to factor into their decision making.

PlayStation offers up PlayStation Plus which regularly cycles free games for the PlayStation 4, PS Vita, PSVR and the PS3 too if that’s something you’re still playing. If you own multiple consoles in the PlayStation family, you’re definitely getting a nice bang for your buck. The PS4 has a Community feature where people can join groups consisting of other like-minded gamers to talk or play games with one another. The PS4 also has one of the easiest to use live streaming and video capture features thanks to the Share button. The Share button makes it very simple to take screenshots, capture videos of your gameplay, or to start streaming directly to Twitch. Also, if you have a PS Vita, there’s an extra perk of being able to stream your PS4 to your PS Vita using the internet via remote play which is a very handy feature indeed. Finally, the PS4 Pro has a very clean and simple to use UI which will appeal to those that don’t care about anything other than getting in and out of their games and apps as quickly as humanly possible.

The Xbox One X has similar competing features, but with their own spin. Games with Gold depending on the month is better, worse, or equal to PlayStation Plus, it all comes down to personal preference on the rotating games. However, Xbox One X does have the Xbox Game Pass, which by most accounts is a superior service to PlayStation Now. Everything is subjective based on your preference with the games, of course, but the Game Pass has the huge advantage of being able to download the games rather than having to stream them and is also half the price.

The Xbox One X new UI is considerably more cumbersome to navigate and record/share pictures when compared to the simplicity of just using the Share button and clicking around the PS4’s minimal UI. That said, the Xbox One UI does a better job of actually connecting players. Clubs and LFG are better integrated into the UI of the Xbox One rather than being hidden away for the most part on the PS4, and are more fleshed out with more features. If sharing and accessing content with your friends is something you care about, or you don’t have many friends that play with you and want to make new ones, the Xbox One does a better job at least of facilitating that than the PS4.

Games

Xbox One X vs. PS4 Pro

Now here is where things get dicey. The PS4 Pro and Xbox One X have a ton of overlap when it comes to third-party games, but quite a large difference in console exclusives. The PS4 has received more console exclusives to-date than the Xbox One, and this trend appears to be likely to continue into the near future. It’s not that the Xbox One doesn’t have any, they do, and generally, they are very well received. Still, in terms of pure numbers both past, present, and future, the PS4 Pro definitely has an edge here. It comes down to your personal preference, though. If you like the Xbox One exclusives game better and aren’t interested in the PS4’s exclusives, then the number of exclusives is kind of irrelevant.

One area where the Xbox One X does trump the PS4 Pro when it comes to games, though, is backwards compatibility. As of right now, there’s a handful of PlayStation 2 classics able to be purchased, along with the PlayStation Now catalog of games that can be streamed but that’s pretty much it. You can’t pop a PS3 disc into your PS4 Pro and start playing. Not only can the Xbox One X do that for a large number of games, but it also enhances it, allowing them to run better than they did on the Xbox 360 and original Xbox. It’s not going to make games feel like remastered versions, but it’s better than no upgrade at all.

The Verdict: Should You Buy an Xbox One X if You Already Own a PS4 Pro?

Both consoles are incredibly impressive machines and are the apex predators in terms of power this generation. That said, if you already own a PS4 Pro, the Xbox One X isn’t distinct enough to be worth picking up as well. If you don’t own either yet, that’s a different conversation entirely, and you can check out our full review to get a better sense of which direction you should go in.

So on a very basic level, no, the Xbox One X is not worth getting if you already own a PS4 Pro.

Consider these more specific questions and scenarios as well though:

What if you really care about playing Xbox One exclusives? – If you care about saving money, grab an Xbox One S instead. They play all of the same games.

Is your number #1 factor when buying a console for it to be as best looking as possible? – If that’s really important to you, then sure trade in your PS4 Pro, or just buy an Xbox One X, because it is more powerful than the PS4 Pro. That said, the PS4 Pro is also pretty damn good, and also has a long list of unique features that we discussed above.

Do you have a strong desire to play some old Xbox 360 games again without having to hook it back up to your TV? – In this scenario, we still recommend grabbing the Xbox One S if that’s the case. You’ll still have backwards compatibility and access to Xbox Game Pass which has lots of quality 360 games on there as well.

Are you really into PC gaming? – Then you can probably get away with just having a PS4 and a PC, and if you want to add something else on, grab a Nintendo Switch instead to have the widest library possible. You’d only be missing out on a few games that can only be played on the Xbox One/X.

Do you struggle to find people to play with and want robust community features to help? – The Xbox One consoles do a better job of this than the PS4, but again, you can get away with just getting an Xbox One S instead. Don’t trade a PS4 in though just for that though, just add on an Xbox One if you can.