5. Call of Duty 2
It’s difficult to follow up a game of the year with a sequel that even comes a little close to matching the original’s glory. Even more so when both games are WWII shooters. But Call of Duty 2 exploded out of the starting gate with a great campaign and a much more superior multiplayer experience than the original. Compared to some of the lackluster titles in the franchise, Call of Duty 2 stands proud.